Synkatathesis

SYNKATATHESIS is ‘assent’. In Stoicism, it refers to the act of approving impressions, conceptions, and judgments which therefore prompts action to take place.

This is the third level of self-coherence, concerning the will/judgement and what we choose to reject. In fact, <synkatathesis> is part of a sequence whose task is for us to face reality. Firstly, there is <aisthesis> which results from the activation of our senses. For instance, if a stone hits our face a set of sensations is immediately operating and we receive several stimuli.

Sokratiko Logo

Secondly, there is <phantasia> which is the representation of the stimuli when passing from senses to soul. As an example, while <aisthesis> gives us the sensations of pain (or penetration, piercing, smashing, hurting and so on), <phantasia> gives us the idea of an object hitting our face, maybe not too big, possibly a stone. <Phantasiai> are produced not only by external objects but also by internal conditions, like virtue or vice. Nonetheless, these two events (sense impressions and soul representations) are mainly of a passive kind. Our free choice is not involved.

Thirdly, there is <synkatathesis>. This is the <logos> inside ourselves (as a mirror of the universal <logos>) deliberating to give assent or not (or even suspending the judgement) to representations. In this third case a choice is in play, although the same choice depends on the nature of the representation.

<Synkatathesis> is ‘assent’. But ‘assent’ itself is not entirely our choice. In other words, our conscience cannot dissent in front of the “smashing” evidence of a stone hitting our face (maybe thinking it is just a water downpour). When something like that happens, it means we are mad or anyway not in control of ourselves (for instance, because of drugs or alcohol).